Showing posts with label Football Federation Australia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Football Federation Australia. Show all posts

Thursday, 24 June 2021

Episode 85 - Establishing and maintaining Australian soccer history's web presence

Download and listen to this episode here. 

This week Paul is joined in hosting duties in the studio by Greg Stock, and remotely by Garry McKenzie.

Paul notes that he received a present from Greg in the mail, which took so long to arrive that Greg ended up in Melbourne before it. Paul wraps up some Football Belongs feedback, including a tribute at Edensor Park for Ivan "Gilligan" Rendulic. Garry discusses trying to figure out whether there was a family connection between Alec Gibb (Socceroo #51) and Angus "Billy" Gibb (Socceroo #51a) - and an explanation of how mistakes like "missing" Socceroos get made, and then corrected. Greg talks about the process of starting the process of rehabilitating the accuracy of OzFootball's National Soccer League records, and the processes involved in making decisions when informed by sources with contradictory information. We also look at the revamped format of the pages, which will include links to match programs and match footage.

Our main discussion this week focuses on Football Australia's relaunch of the historical online pages, and the status of the equivalent state pages - where they exist. We discuss the holes and shortcomings and mistakes of FA's effort, but we also acknowledge that it's a massive step in the right direction, and we look forward to seeing how future improvements, now that the framework is in place. Especially pleasing is that the Hall of Fame has now been updated significantly from its previous semi-derelict state. And how much information is too much? And what's the next step? And how maybe, just maybe, that the existence of an Australian soccer history community means things like this project happen.

But going around the state federation history websites, and while the situation generally shows improvement from previous efforts, there are still several federations with negligible online historical presence. So far have we progressed since we last did a deep dive on this issue all the way back in episode 6? Who's the benchmark now? What resources are being allocated for improvements? What's going on in the background?

In the final segment, it's a Garry McKenzie curated 100 Years Ago Today, where Garry notes that Ipswich clubs were dominating the main Queensland league competition, and the first mention of the Tristram Shield; then to Weston, and the death of a local soccer player known only as "Pearce"; there's also the death of Edwin (Teddy) Aldred, an English footballer who had played for Leeds City's reserves, an had an extended - albeit contested - history of playing soccer in Australia; and we look at the beginnings of women's soccer in Australia, as discussions start in the press about going ahead with such a project.

Thursday, 5 November 2020

Episode 63 - Andy Harper, on resetting narratives and Australian soccer's issue of legitimacy

Download and listen to this episode here.

We begin the show by noting that, unfortunately, due to New South Wales opening its borders to Victoria on November 23rd, Ian and Paul will not be able to make an appearance at the Football Writers Festival.

Then we move onto a perfunctory clean up - Mark Boric, George Cotsanis, Tony Persoglia.

Then a discussion led by Ian about researching Australian women's soccer and other women's codes, especially with regards to an old search he conducted on Trove many years ago.

Our guest this week is Andy Harper, former professional footballer in the National Soccer League, and latterly a commentator and author. Harper joins Ian and Paul to discuss the problem with the search for grand and/or unifying narratives in Australian soccer. Our discussion is prompted by Andy's dissatisfaction with Principle II of FFA's XI Principles For the Future of Australian Football - especially with regards to its focus on the faulty assertion that Australian soccer has always been multicultural, as well the constant desire to reset the narrative of Australian soccer in search of 'fresh starts'.

In a lengthy discussion, Ian, Paul, and Andy also discuss these and other matters within the scope of Andy's recently completed doctoral thesis (completed via publication), which utilises Weber's theories on legitimacy to argue that soccer's problem of a lack of cultural and institutional legitimacy is ingrained into Australian culture. The chat takes in discussions about Britishness, Australianness, different forms of legitimacy and how are they gained and lost; and the self-interest, short-term thinking, and niche interests portrayed as being reflective of the greater good. It's all a bit highbrow!

But don't take Paul's mangled summary for it, listen to it yourself!

Unfortunately, 100 Years Ago Today did not go ahead this week - but we think the extended chat with Andy was worth the sacrifice. 

Thursday, 25 June 2020

Episode 44 - The death of Walter William Williams

Download and listen to episode 44 here.

We begin this episode with the Mark Boric Express has been uploading late 1970s and early 1980s Marconi match programs, originally scanned and uploaded by Edgar Spath.

We follow up on last week's discussion on the fate of the extant 15 years worth of A-League match archives, and the reformatted A-League broadcast deal. FFA has manged, as part of its giving up a chunk of its due broadcast revenue, to secure the rights to the full 15 years of A-League archives. No news on whether the FFA Cup footage is part of that deal, nor pre-season tournament footage.

Then a brief discussion about the cultural implications on moving back to winter, and the question of freedom of choice to be a multi-sport fan which was introduced when the . This is followed by a mangled attempt at an analogy attempting to compare the way that broadcasters don't use their archival footage, to the way that major brewers protect trademarks and products which they have not used or produced for decades.

Then just before the break, Ian raises the matter of an article brought to his attention by Garry Mackenzie, about the early organisation of Melbourne soccer - which hints at the possible existence of soccer in Melbourne going back several years prior to the first documented games in 1883.

An extract from the coroner's report into the death
of Walter Williams in 1920, sourced via State 
Library access to the Ancestry.com database 
After the break we launch into a special edition of 100 Years Ago Today. We begin with a visit to Launceston and a pavilion-less York Park; then to Adelaide, where teams representing 'South' and 'North' play a scratch match to select a team to play against the HMS Renown in a game to be witnessed by the Prince of Wales; then to Melbourne, for the weekend's ongoing confusing results, including a game that was called off.

Then to Burnie, whose local paper inexplicably reports on the most serious weekend injuries in Victoria's football codes, including two broken legs in Aussie Rules, and a serious concussion suffered by a soccer player. That injured soccer player was Walter William Williams, who died from the injury.

Digging deeper into Williams' story, it is revealed that Williams was an English migrant from south-east London - possibly  arriving in Australia as part  of a migrant farm worker program, living in Carlton at the time of his death. In late 1914 he signed up for the AIF while living in Casterton, in south-west Victoria. He participates in the Gallipoli campaign, before being captured by the Turks. During the war, he appears to have suffered serious head injuries.

This mini-project serves as an example of the ways to use the wide variety of resources and networks at our disposal - state library digital resources, military service databases, online newspaper databases, and the coroner's reports - as well as utilising the skill sets and interests of various Australian soccer historians to build an incomplete picture of:

  • Who Walter Williams was, and how he came to be playing soccer in Melbourne for Preston.
  • The unfolding of the incident which led to Williams' death.
  • The way the police dealt with the investigation, and their lack of awareness of soccer in Melbourne
  • The eye-witness accounts of the incidents of those who were at the game, as well as a character reference from someone who seems to have served in the armed forces with Williams.
  • The reaction of the local soccer community Williams' death, and their purchase of a headstone for Williams' grave at Coburg Cemetery, a headstone which apparently has since been removed.
Key to this, as asserted earlier, is the importance of the resources and networks available to discover these kinds of stories. The goal in cases like this is to try and establish the social, cultural, and family networks soccer players existed in; building a repository of tools to use when researching these matters; appreciating the historical networks at our disposal.

Thursday, 18 June 2020

Episode 43 - Paul Hunt and the Australian Trustees Soccer Football Association

An example of Mark Taylor's sketchbooks, this one
being from Stratford United vs Edge Hill from a Far
North Queensland competition in 1992.  
Download and listen to episode 43 here.

We begin this episode by recommending people go to the Australian Football Before the A-League Facebook page, where a poster named Mark Taylor has been uploading pages from his sketchbooks. These extracts document Mark's journeys to an assortment of Australian soccer matches up and down the eastern coast and Tasmania. The sketchbooks include details such as lineups, kits, results, and stadium layouts for games Mark saw while doing seasonal farm work along the eastern seaboard

We canvass the potential archival situation from the fallout from the seeming breakdown in relations between FFA and Fox Sports - namely, what happens to the 15 years worth of Australian soccer archives if the relationship between FFA and Fox Sports ends? We look at the likely outcomes based upon precedent - that is, that FFA would still be allowed to use archival footage for marketing, promotional, and special or limited purposes. But we also broaden the discussion - like who owns and who should own this broadcast product, which is also in effect a public cultural product?

We also look at the difficulty at currently being able to access Australian soccer archival footage from various broadcasters, even and especially when those broadcaster show little regard for its value - including commercial, cultural, and social value.  We look at the problem that even when an organisation becomes defunct, its copyright over cultural products remains present long aftet its demise.

After that, Ian quickly raises the matter of 1922 and the centenary of Australia's soccer first men's 'A' international against New Zealand, and nascent plans to visit such a game (should it be held) in Dunedin.

The Tasmanian soccer phrase 'slice of cheese'
 made  it into this global football glossary. 
After the break we talk with returning guest, Tasmanian soccer historian Paul Hunt, who has found evidence of what may be Australia's first interstate club soccer competition. But before that we discuss with him the fact that Tasmanian soccer has managed a degree of international notoriety by being included in Tom Williams' global football glossary Do You Speak Football, thanks to the phrase "slice of cheese" (for a yellow card) making Williams' list. "Slice of cheese"/ is joined in the Australian section of the book by "shoot farken", and Ned Zelic's trademark phrase "individual brilliance" - though surprisingly one of Australian soccer's best known items of football vernacular, "wogball", failed to get a jersey.

After the introductory formalities, we look at how Paul Hunt found what appeared to be interstate fixtures in Tasmania in 1920, played under the auspices of a body called the Australian Trustees Soccer Football Association. Ian, Paul, and Paul discuss how we watched the results of Paul Hunt's and Garry Mackenzie's Trove searches unfold in real time on social media, revealing the ATSFA not be a renegade soccer body, but rather a Sydney based organisation which facilitated something akin to a works competition for middle class employees in the banking and insurance industries. Sydney appears to have operated a six team competition - first under company names, later district names - from about 1917 to 1920.

We ask Paul who these players were, where did they come from, and where did they go one the league folded? Were they predominantly English and Scots? We discuss the nature of the Sydney competition, and the what its existence suggests about the strength of soccer as a sport in Sydney. We also look at the interstate competition held between various state trustee league champions, including teams from Adelaide and Ipswich - the latter interesting in light of it being a sign of middle class soccer amid a strong working class soccer culture. And we look at the interstate trustees competition final, played in Bathurst of all places so that the game would be held at an appropriately neutral venue.

In 100 Years Ago Today, we first visit Maitland for a Marist brothers game; Armidale playing against a team from Glen Innes; strange quasi-poetry from Fremantle; returning soldiers in Toowoomba coming back and reforming their clubs; and of course, the results of the previous week's games in Melbourne.

We finish off the show with a quick look by Paul at an FFA hosted webinar on Andrew Howe's work charting the origins of Socceroos and Matildas players, hosted by Ann Odong, and including Joe Gorman to add some colour. Howe's data rich work on this front - which has been presented in a number of formats and conferences in the past, and which has been the basis of both his Socceroos and Matildas (along with Greg Werner) encyclopaedias, is impressive. Paul discusses the nature of attempting to run a webinar on historical topics and how it played out here; the need for more time for audience questions and participation; and the need for the Australian soccer public to take the hard data of Howe's work and create meaning from it, drawing out stories, trends, narratives.