Showing posts with label George and George Cup. Show all posts
Showing posts with label George and George Cup. Show all posts

Thursday, 10 September 2020

Episode 55 - Vince Manno, and the Victorian Police Soccer Club

Download and listen to this episode here.


We begin the episode by congratulating Andy Harper for receiving his PhD in Australian soccer history.  George Cotsanis has been uploading photos from the collection of Brunswick Juventus player Dino DeMarchi, of Juventus in the 1960s. This leads to a brief segue into discussions of soccer temporarily claiming grounds vacated by Australian Rules and rugby league teams which sought new audiences and facilities in suburbia. We then go into a brief discussion of the history of works teams in New South Wales in the 1930s, and whether the players for those company teams were also employed by the companies.

This leads into a chat about social/works team football, prompted by the reminiscences of well known Victorian referee Alan Clark, and equivalent characters from the Sydney scene. They describe what was once a healthy work based soccer (and sport) scene, which for soccer often included teams made up of ex-NSL and state league players. Clark's posts on the Australian Football Before the A-League Facebook page also point towards one factor in the decline in company sports teams - the costs of dealing with workers compensation claims which came from employees injured while playing for teams effectively endorsed by the relevant company.

Ian then expounds on the puzzling nature of the Tasmanian press' seeming obsession with soccer violence and injuries from outside Tasmania - a line of inquiry which Paul thinks needs more data for the making of an effective comparison. The finally - for now - trying to figure where exactly Melbourne soccer stops in the 1890s, and whether Ian's previous research has stopped short of the actual stop in competition. (hint: yes, he did)

Our guest this week is Vince Manno, of the Victoria Police Soccer Club, who is attempting gather information on the history of the VPSC as well as members of Victoria Police who have also played soccer in mainline competitions. We cover:

  • The history of the Victorian Police Soccer Club, which was born in the late 19
    Logo for Taxation United, the soccer 
    club of the Australian Tax Office.
    40s, which ibcludes its initial formation by migrant British officers; its participation in the Victorian league system in the 1950s; and then eventually becoming an outlet for social, charity, and public goodwill fixtures.
  • This includes charity matches such as the Tony Clarke Memorial Shield, as well as games againsr
  • The VPSC's place within the broader sporting and social wing of the Victorian Police force.
  • The small advantages that researching in this field has over others - including being able to gain access to Victorian Police personnel files, and the existence of Victoria Police museum.
  • The disadvantages in researching Victorian Police involvement with soccer - in particular the existence of the VPSC outside the bounds of mainline competition for most of its history - but especially the obstacle of database searches for "police" and "soccer" more often often than not turning up results for violent incidents at soccer matches, or related court proceedings.
  • The charitable and social nature of the modern day VPSC being to get press in smaller, localised publications, such as suburban press, while the activity of Victoria Police related to 
  • The difficulty in tracking members of Victoria Police who play in mainline competitions, whose identity as Victoria Police officers is not at the forefront of their soccer identity. 
If anyone has information, photographs, or memorabilia, please contact Paul at blackmissionary@hotmail.com, so we can pass them along to Vince Manno. 

In 100 Years Ago Today, most of the soccer seasons around the country are beginning to wrap up. We begin in Lithgow, with a notice of finals matches; then to Brisbane, where the Corinthians hold a dance, while old rivals Thistles and Pineapple Rovers square off; then to Newcastle, where Ian notes that one article starts with commending the officiating rather than making mention of the match - in the same article we ponder at the possibility that Weston was punished with regards to hosting a Gardiner Cup tie, because of their having left the South Maitland association; then finally o Melbourne, where Ian demonstrates - using an extreme example - the difficulty in cleaning up Trove's attempts at  text recognition; and finally half a match report, and the final score from the final of Melbourne's 1920 league season. 

Thursday, 11 July 2019

Episode 13 - Adamstown Rosebud's 130th anniversary; Leopold Baumgartner

Download and listen to episode 13 here.

Apologies for another week missed. But we're back for another episode with a lot to clean up.

We start with little bit about the soccer exhibition at Deakin University in Geelong, highlighting what's available in the Schwab and Shorrock collections at Deakin.

Then Ian and Paul wonder about Mark Boric's collection and the long-term security of the database, and whether it would be better if someone with money and clout came into secure the future of the collection. But remember what the Meat Puppets said? "Who needs action when you've got words".

Ian talks about progress on his 'First Kicks' project. Oh, the complications of delineating between suburbs, cities, towns, villages, and the passage of time that changes them.

And the rivalry between the George and George Cup and the Beaney Cup for importance in 1880s Melbourne.

Then 100 Years Ago Today. The Spanish flu is on the wane. The code is regenerating. And first to Broken Hill, where the local soccer folk are trying to get the game going again. At the centre of things are working people and trade unionism, and an interesting fellow named Reg Rapley. Then to Melbourne, where league competition is finally getting underway... almost. That's followed by a soccer/rugby league double header in Newcastle... and how things have changed since then.

After the break we speak with John Connors from Adamstown Rosebud, on the club's 130th anniversary. We delve into the club's early days and the social context the club existed in - covering class, religion, and other clubs of the same vintage - before moving on to discuss the club's war dead.

The discussion is capped off with a look at Adamstown's short-lived tenure in the National Soccer Leagye in the 1980s - an era which brought surprise glory, in the form of an NSL Cup win (and another missing trophy); but also disaster, with the club's then significant wealth squandered on just three NSL seasons.

In the final segment, Paul looks at The Little Professor of Soccer by Leopold Baumgartner, a classic of Australian soccer publishing.

The book covers Baumgartner's life from his early days in Austria, until the near the end of his playing career. It's a bit of a let down that the book doesn't go beyond that, as Baumgartner remained engaged in soccer in various guises for the rest of his life, especially coaching junior soccer.

The first half or so of the book centres on Baumgartner's youth and pathway to professional soccer in Austria - which was still a semi-professional pursuit. Baumgartner talks about his trips with the Austrian national youth team, and club trips touring South America, where the somewhat naive sounding narrator marvels at the cross-national bonhomie of European youth football but also note the grinding poverty he encounters in Latin America

These overseas tours eventually lead to Baumgartner and players of his ilk, migrating to Australia to play for clubs like Sydney's Prague and Hakoah clubs. Of course this leads to the mess of Australia being kicked out of FIFA for not paying transfers to the European clubs. But the imports at least bring advanced tactics, preparation and skill to Australia, as well as boosting crowds.

Baumgartner plays for a variety of clubs and undertakes a variety of roles, but if there's one thing which irks him it's football politics. The pettiness of internal club politics, and the incompetence of federation officials really get up Baumgartner's goat.

The lasting impact of this book is a strange one - the collective memory of the culture that this book talks about is gone. Many of the clubs are dead; the rest, even the strongest, a mere shadow of what they were. A book that begins so full of naivety and hope ends with the sobering warning that Australian soccer in the late 1960s is already on the decline, and that something must be done to arrest that downward turn.

The book is long out of print, but you can download a sneaky scanned copy here.

Sunday, 18 November 2018

Episode 2 - Australian soccer and literature; Extended trophy discussion

Download and listen to episode 2 here,

Rudderless without George Donikian's guiding hand, Ian and Paul cast off into uncharted waters. The first ten minutes meander with attempts to put forward a manifesto, or at least some sort of method - only committed listeners will find out if any of these regular segments actually materialise.

The whole world then celebrates Paul's finally getting his thesis passed. The thesis was about the relationship between Australian soccer and literature, and soccer and Australian literature,
  • the difficulty about talking sport and the arts at the same time in Australian culture.
  • the paucity of academic and community awareness of Australian sporting literature.
  • the Austlit database, which is accessible via university databases for those in the tertiary sector, and via state library websites.
  • the many ways in which the literature differs in its discourses from the ways in which journalism and mainline histories discuss the experience of Australian soccer
  • the ways in which the literature challenges monolithic understandings of Australian soccer in terms of ethnicity and gender readings.
  • the idea that demographers, historians, sociologists etc have not taken literature seriously when looking at the Australian sporting experience.
  • an extended discussion on The Earth Cries Out, Harold C. Wells' novel on mining in the Hunter, which includes occasional snippets on soccer.
After the break, the discussion moves to missing trophies, and particularly Victoria's Beaney Cup, and the George and George Cup, and the sage of their theft, pawning, and involvement in court cases. The discussion also touches on the virtual disappearance of soccer from Victoria during the 1890s and early 1900s.

Then onto the Gardiner Cup, New South Wales' long-running knockout cup, and a discussion of the nature (and material value) of trophies, and the cultural difference between trophies and pennants. Then a discussion on the FA Trophy, which was donated by the Football Association for interstate competition in Australia, which was assumed missing... but is it actually?

And then onto the very well-known story of the fate of the Australia Cup trophy... and how soccer cultures evolve in the things that they care (and don't care about), and the ways in which people in the game take care of historical artefacts - and what happens to a club's trophies if the club goes defunct? And who is responsible for maintaining those artefacts? Oh, and that dreaded museum debate...