Thursday 29 October 2020

Episode 62 - reviewing 100 Years Of Moreland City documentary, with Jason Gioldsmith

Download and listen to this episode here.

A reminder that the Football Writers Festival is happening on the 21st and 22nd of November in Sydney.

Mark Boric Express continues, with copies of Brisbane's Soccer News. George Cotsanis is wondering why a video of Indonesia vs Australia from 1980 is ratcheting up the views.

Oh, and a quick follow up on Dr Snowden Hay from last week, thanks to Paul Hunt,

A look at the Rainford Cup, which is in the United Kingdom for some reason, after being in Sydney,, after being in the UK.

Then some more on soccer in Murray Bridge, with more on GR Handley, a soccer administrator with many hands in many pots. Media, mutual respect between codes, Britishness, social events, and the rise and fall of soccer and other sports in the region all get an airing, 

We're joined this week by returning guest (and occasional co-host) Jason Goldsmith, to discuss the 2016 documentary Moreland City -100 Years Strong, which was produced by George Donikian. We discuss:

  • Mythologies, origins, and the problems with making judgements with exceedingly scarce information, and the "1916 problem".
  • Not much information on pre-1945.
  • The doco's seeming emphasis on Moreland ahead of Park Rangers and Coburg (and Brunswick and Hakoah)
  • The lack of chat about the grounds the various clubs used other than Campbell Reserve
  • British migration stories, and the involvement of Ten Pound Poms (and Scots) in Melbourne soccer (and the lack of insight into the lack of broader involvement in local soccer by that group).
  • Moreland's 1950s success (trophy and player-wise) accelerating that club's decline into irrelevance at the hands of the ethnic clubs.
  • The difficulty in making mergers work, especially with a local rival.
  • The feelings of loss and only gradual feeling of a new club being equal (or close to) in your heart as your fist club.
  • Missing out on the journey up the leagues, and whether parts of the club ethos have changed in their rise up the leagues - including professionalism.
  • The good archival content, especially photographic and artefact content.
If you are interested in viewing this documentary, please contact the Moreland City club.

(Paul reviewed this film upon first viewing it back in 2016 - you need to scroll down a bit)

In 100 Years Ago Today we head to Newcastle; some pointed commentary about the "Irish" national team from an Adelaide newspaper; A Brisbane report about an upcoming women's football international between Britain and France; and Sydney reports about other international games.

No comments:

Post a Comment